Shareholder disputes commonly arise when there are disagreements between shareholders, company directors or officers regarding the management of a company, shareholders’ rights, company finances or the direction of the business.
These disputes can significantly impact the operation and value of a company if the matters are not appropriately and strategically addressed.
You should seek legal advice when concerns arise, particularly where there are allegations of:
If one of these issues apply to you, early intervention can often assist to preserve the commercial relationship and avoid lengthy litigation. For the full range of corporate legal services, see our corporate lawyers page.
Your rights as a shareholder differ depending on whether the company is public or private.
In general, shareholders have the right to:
For public companies:
For private companies:
Breach of Directors’ Duties
Directors owe a range of statutory and fiduciary duties to the company and its shareholders under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
The relevant provisions are sections 180-183 which impose duties on directors’ and officers’, such as the:
Further, in certain circumstances, breaches of the duty to act in good faith and for a proper purpose that arises out of recklessness or dishonesty can result in criminal liability (see section 184 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)).
See Corporate Governance Lawyers for more information.
Oppressive Conduct Claims
A shareholder can initiate proceedings when there has been oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly discriminatory conduct against a member or members of the company.
Under section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), shareholders can apply to the Court where there has been conduct of a company’s affair that is:
Examples of matters where oppressive conduct may be present include:
There are remedies available to shareholders under section 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), for example:
Where shareholder disputes proceed to Supreme Court or Federal Court proceedings, our civil and commercial litigation lawyers act for both applicants and respondents.
Yes, they can be. Where directors issue new shares to dilute a minority shareholder’s interest and that conduct is oppressive under section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the court can order the directors to compensate the shareholder personally under section 233. In Aulich v Scott [2026] FCAFC 139, the Full Court of the Federal Court upheld such an order, even though one of the companies had already been wound up. The decision applies to Australian companies, including NSW private companies.
What happened in Aulich v Scott
A shareholder held 25% of two private companies and asked to be bought out. Instead, the directors issued new shares at $1 each. The new shares were offered to every shareholder in proportion to their holding, but she declined to put in more money, and her stake fell to a fraction of one per cent. The trial judge found the share issues were made principally to dilute her, with no genuine commercial reason, and ordered two of the directors to compensate her personally (Scott v Aulich [2025] FCA 1329). On 30 October 2026 the Full Court dismissed the directors’ appeal. Compensation was measured as the value of her shareholding immediately before each dilution, less dividends she later received.
Key points for shareholders and directors
Not every capital raising is oppressive. Courts are slow to second-guess a genuine, honestly made management decision to raise capital, even if a shareholder who does not take up new shares is diluted. What decided Aulich v Scott was a dilutive purpose combined with no real commercial justification. Directors planning a share issue while a shareholder wants to exit should get advice first and document the commercial reason, the valuation, and the alternatives considered.
Legal proceedings can be brought on behalf of the company for the purpose of taking responsibility, known as a derivative action. An application can be made in accordance with section 237 to commence proceedings under section 236 on behalf of the company, which must be granted leave by the Court. The process is referred to as a Statutory Derivative Action which is the mechanism whereby persons can sue on a company’s behalf. A derivative action is used when a company is failing to take action against a legal claim that is available to them. Should this occur, shareholders and select officers can seek permission from the court to bring proceedings on behalf of the company.
A shareholder oppression claim brought under section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) has remedies available under section 233.
Further, under section 1324 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the Court can grant an injunction on the terms that it deems appropriate.
Injunctions are commonly sought in order to:
To minimise the risk of future shareholder disputes, a well-drafted shareholders agreement is essential. See our guide to shareholders agreements for the key provisions that protect all parties, including provisions that:
Where the dispute involves an unincorporated partnership rather than a company, see our partnership disputes lawyers page.
Our shareholder dispute lawyers act for shareholders, directors and companies from our Sydney CBD office and for clients throughout Greater Sydney and NSW, including Parramatta, Chatswood, North Sydney, Liverpool, Penrith, Ryde, Bondi Junction, the Inner West, Sutherland Shire, Hornsby, Burwood, Bankstown, Manly and Newtown, as well as regional NSW.
Claims under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), including oppression claims under section 232, are generally brought in the Supreme Court of New South Wales or the Federal Court of Australia in Sydney. Early advice and negotiation can usually be handled by phone, email and video meeting.
If your shareholding has been diluted or you have been shut out, call (02) 9233 7737 for a free initial phone consultation.
Citilawyers understands the commercial and personal complexities that often arise within shareholder disputes. Our team provides strategic and practical advice that is aimed at protecting your interests.
We advise shareholders, directors and companies in relation to:
Whether you are seeking to protect your rights as a shareholder or respond to allegations made against you, Citilawyers can assist you through every stage. Contact us online or call (02) 9233 7737.